Fair Distribution | COVID-19 Vaccine | UPSC

Spread the love

Fair Distribution _ COVID-19 Vaccine _ UPSC

Fair Distribution | COVID-19 Vaccine | UPSC

      HEADLINES:

COVID-19: What will be a fair policy to distribute vaccine

      WHY IN NEWS:

The question of equitable distribution of a vaccine is as much a global concern as it is local

SYLLABUS COVERED: GS 4 : Medical Ethics : Fair Distribution | COVID-19 Vaccine | UPSC

      LEARNING: 

  • You will understand the dire need of a policy.
  • Questions popping out of this issue
  • Role of state

      ISSUE: 

There are many aspects to the distribution of a vaccine, including economic, demographic, logistic, legal, socio-political, etc.

FAIR POLICY TO DISTRIBUTE VACCINE

  • There are ethical aspect as well, which demands an equitable policy of distribution.

WHY WE NEED A POLICY

  • We also know that the pandemic is a global phenomenon, and any piecemeal or local management would not suffice.
  • It is imperative that a global policy of distribution be in place so that all countries can receive the benefit almost simultaneously.
  • No country is safe if only its own citizens are inoculated.

UNANSWERED QUESTIONS

  • Question of an ethical and equitable distribution of the vaccine is as much a global concern as it is local.
  • Is there a moral obligation on the part of a country to help the distant needy ?

Who decides how much of the vaccine produced should go to other countries and at what cost?

  • Do agencies funding the research or the researchers or government authorities or citizens decide on a global policy of distribution?
  • It is a known fact that when a quantity of an export increases, the cost of resource in the exporting country also increases.

Should citizens of that country bear the burden of the extra cost ?
 

  • Don’t they all deserve to get the vaccine, before any surplus is sent to another country?
  • Would the exporting country be justified in charging a higher price for the vaccine than its actual cost?
  • The cost of the vaccine and its possible loss will have to be borne by someone.

In the distributive hierarchy, it is always the last receiver that has to bear the cost — likely to be the more vulnerable and needy people of the society.

DISTRIBUTION

  • How do we circumvent the human and economic cost of this eventuality?
  • This brings us to the other question about the modalities of distributing a scarce resource locally.

What ethical principles should guide the local distribution of the vaccine?

  • Should it be determined by need, affordability, vulnerability or some other criterion or a combination of all?
  • It may be argued that healthcare workers fighting the pandemic at the forefront are most vulnerable to contracting the disease and hence they need to get it first.
  • Alternatively, one could argue that the elderly with comorbidities need the vaccine first.
  • But then, the elderly are not fighting the virus at the forefront, so they may not be at a greater risk.
  • Again, one could argue that those in 18-50 age group, who have to step out of their homes for a living would need the vaccine first.
  • So, do they deserve the vaccine first while the health workers get the protective gear and the elderly stays at home?

Should open market forces determine the cost of the vaccine and affordability?

      IASbhai WINDUP: 

Several factors such as the population size, demographics, indigenous production capacities, short- and long-term needs, affordability and vulnerability will have to be kept in mind .

  • This would be a policy that would need to be reviewed and reframed.
  • To make sure that that does not happen, the government would need to intervene to regulate and cap the price to avoid profiteering
  • The issue would again be a matter of local / national policy.

The state has to evolve with an equitable principle that treats all stakeholders fairly.
 

  • These are not easy questions to answer.
  • In fact, they become all the more difficult when the race is against time.
  • We need to put our heads together to figure out a local as well as a global policy of distribution.
  • Such policy should benefits as well as the burdens of this much-valued resource in the most equitable manner.

It is important that we garner public opinion about how this task is to be accomplished and the war against COVID-19 won.

     SOURCES:THE HINDU & PIB | Fair Distribution | COVID-19 Vaccine | UPSC

READ MORE : GS-4

If you liked this article, then please subscribe to our YouTube Channel for Daily Current Affairs , Editorial Analysis & Answer writing video tutorials. You can also find us on Twitter and Facebook.


Spread the love

You have successfully subscribed to the newsletter

There was an error while trying to send your request. Please try again.

IASbhai will use the information you provide on this form to be in touch with you and to provide updates and marketing.